|  Sep 15, 2015

Michigan Governor Snyder sets clean power example for GOP governors

Kelley WelfKelley Welf, Communications Director
Michigan Governor Snyder sets clean power example for GOP governors
Kelley WelfKelley Welf, Communications Director

A breath of fresh, clean, air breezed across the state of Michigan this month when Governor Rick Snyder’s administration announced that Michigan will file a State Implementation Plan in compliance with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s Clean Power Plan (CPP). 

Governor Snyder is the first Republican Governor to announce a plan to comply with the CPP, making his announcement particularly notable. Ironically, Snyder’s announcement comes as Michigan’s Republican Attorney General Bill Schuette and 15 other attorneys general are petitioning the U.S. Court of Appeals to issue an emergency stay of the federal clean power rules.  At issue for Schuette is not only what he deems government over-regulation, but also concern about the rule costing jobs and increasing the price of electricity for Michigan families.

Let’s set the record straight.  The six major renewable energy industries employ over 600,000 Americans nationwide with good family-supporting jobs.  The U.S. wind turbine manufacturing industry has become a vibrant source of economic activity. More than 500 manufacturing facilities provide investment and quality jobs in communities in 44 states across the country.  American Wind Energy Association data indicates that Michigan has 33 wind industry manufacturers and ranks 4th in the country for wind component manufacturing; neighboring Illinois has 39 manufacturing companies and ranks 3rd in the nation.

Illinois’ Republican Governor Bruce Rauner should take note. His own transition report highlighted the positive impact renewable energy has on the state’s economy, and he has publicly stated that climate change is a man-made phenomenon. Rauner could follow Snyder’s example and announce that Illinois will comply with the CPP in a way that helps the state’s economy and leverages its robust renewable energy resource. Such a move would enhance Illinois’ stellar position as a national leader in wind component manufacturing and project development.

Investing in clean power sources under the CPP will save Midwest consumers millions of dollars. The cost of wind energy has fallen by two-thirds over the last six years, and solar installation costs have fallen nearly 40% over the past four years. These cost trends will continue into future decades.

Recent cost savings are now being reflected in Midwesterners’ energy bills. For instance, the Illinois Power Agency found that the state’s existing renewable energy generation reduced wholesale energy prices by $177 million in 2011.  Similarly, Xcel Energy is the nation’s number one wind energy provider and has cited wind’s low cost as the driving factor in their investment in wind. 

“Wind prices are extremely competitive right now, offering lower costs than other possible resources, like natural gas plants,” David Sparby, president and CEO of Northern States Power Co.-Minnesota, an Xcel Energy company, said in a statement in 2013. “These projects offer a great hedge against rising and often volatile fuel prices.  

The same year, Xcel Energy announced that a single wind purchase will save its customers $590 million in fuel costs, noting that “We are making these acquisitions purely on economics and the savings we can deliver to our customers.”

Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest on energy & our work

Even smaller investor-owned utilities, like Minnesota Power that also serves 16 municipal systems, are reaping the benefits of low-cost wind energy. The utility reported recently that the state’s Renewable Energy Standard (25% renewables by 2025) will save their ratepayers $71.2 million dollars by 2029. These savings are driven in large part by very low-cost wind power.

Polls repeatedly show strong favorability for renewable energy across the political spectrum. Republicans who see the value renewable energy brings to their states in terms of jobs, economic development, as well as the environmental benefits, should be applauded and encouraged to stand their ground.   

Renewable energy, especially wind, is reliable and affordable, and drives jobs and economic development. Facts are facts; and the facts point conclusively that renewables should not be the poster child for partisan politics. 

Governor Snyder has taken a bold step in supporting the Clean Power Plan.  His leadership should be an example for his Republican peers across the country. 

This article was first written for and appeared in Morning Consult.

by Kelley WelfKelley Welf
Communications Director

Kelley Welf is the communications director for Clean Grid Alliance. She writes about transmission, MISO, and the benefits of renewable energy across the Midwest. Follow CGA on Twitter @CGA_Midwest, Facebook @cleangridalliance and LinkedIn @clean-grid-alliance.